latest update: October 9, 2023
What I’m Looking For
If you’re looking for my comparison of the Remarkable and Supernote tablets, that’s here.
Ideally, a handwriting-note app would (in order of importance)
- automatically and immediately recognize handwriting and search the handwriting itself (not the recognized text)
- utilize and organize tags
- complete toolbar customization (placement and tools displayed)
- have a precision eraser of any size desirable
- make organizing pages and files/notebooks as easy as on a Mac
- have a clean, pleasant UI
- have access to editable shapes and arrows
- have pens of any size and color desirable
The first five of those are very important, with the rest being nice-to-have; the app must be able to search, and present results within, my handwriting.
There are numerous apps other than the 5 listed in the table below that I was encouraged to try by online reviews but which didn’t come close to what I was looking for. I don’t do subscriptions, so apps like Notability never even crossed my mind. I considered including Penbook, which has lots of options and is visually pleasing, but it’s even more expensive ($50) than Goodnotes (which is already pricey) and it has no file organization (it’s just a list of notebooks).
In my opinion, the six best options for taking notes are Element Note, Goodnotes, Nebo, Noteful, Noteshelf, and ZoomNotes.
With the exception of being able to move the toolbars, ZoomNotes ($7.99; desktop companion app: $6.99) has every feature and function listed in the leftmost column of the table and dozens more, and almost everything is customizable. However… it is chaos incarnate and requires a 123-page manual to operate. (If it weren’t for the extremely reasonable price, I’d think that Adobe developed this app.) It’s not an attractive UI, nor is its structure intuitive (you’re going to need the manual). It is so absolutely overwhelming that I can’t fit everything it does into this table, which is why it does not appear there. (It’s also rather buggy, which isn’t surprising given how many lines of code must be required to run this thing.) If you want to know what it can do, please visit the website or click the direct link to the manual above.
The Analysis
Cost
Category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
One-time Payment | $9.99 | $29.99 | $8.99 | $4.99 | $7.99 |
Subscription Option | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
Tools
Category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Toolbar Customization | Not customizable Undo is a tool… but redo is a menu option (that you have to keep going back to if you want to redo multiple steps); it does offer tap gestures for both features, however | Not customizable Toolbar is very cluttered | Favorite colors can be added or removed | Very customizable Only one color (the current one) stored in toolbar | Very customizable |
Toolbar Location | Top only (one row) | Top or bottom (two rows) Includes tab bar row for multiple documents open at same time | Top only (two rows) | All four sides (one row) Tab bar can be at top or at bottom | Main bar: top only (one row), floating Secondary (palette) bar: upper, middle, or lower left or upper, middle, or lower right; also floating Can be reduced to single icon (i.e., hidden) |
Pens | 9 (two pencils, three pens, two brushes, two markers), any number of which can be displayed in the tool popup; slider for custom size on each | Ball pen, fountain pen, brush; slider for custom size on each | Felt pen, fountain pen, brush; 6 set sizes each | 3 (unnamed, but look like felt-tip pen, fountain pen, and marker); slider for custom size on each | Felt pen, ball pen, fountain pen, pencil; slider for custom size on each Palette stores 3 favorite widths and 3 favorite colors for each pen |
Highlighter | No unique tool, but the “marker” pen is pretty much a highlighter, with a round-tip option as well | Yes; slider for size customization Straight-line setting | Yes; 6 set sizes | Yes; slider for size customization Straight-line setting | Yes; slider for size customization Straight-line setting Includes both flat and round options |
Eraser (“Precise” works like a regular pencil eraser and has various sizes, and “Stroke” deletes everything in the single stroke the eraser touches) | Stroke and Precise The only app with a custom-sized eraser Individual toggles to allow erasure of each pen type (e.g., you could choose to erase any marker or brush writing but leave the pen and pencil writing) | Scratch-to-erase is flaky Stroke and Precise (3 set sizes, all of which are too large w/out zooming in first) Precise has two forms: “precision” (only area within eraser radius is deleted) and “standard” (slight area outside eraser radius is also deleted) | Handy scratch-to-erase feature Stroke and Precise (6 set sizes) | Precise only 5 sizes, but only the smallest seems usable Options to erase whole line, highlights only, shapes, tapes, and auto-select previous tool afterwards | Stroke and Precise 3 fixed sizes and 1 “auto,” which seems to adjust its size depending on how slowly you initially move the Pencil; smallest is a bit too large Options to erase highlighter only, pencil only, and auto-select previous tool afterwards |
Lasso | Least number of popup context-menu options You need to tap in the selected area before popup context menu appears Toggle selectable types (four pens, text box, media, shapes, stickers) Requires the most finesse while using; often grabbed words and objects I didn’t want included | You need to tap in the selected area before popup context menu appears | Popup context menu appears instantly | Freeform or square shape Popup context menu appears instantly Items can be set as immovable (i.e., handwriting, shapes, etc.) | Freeform or square shape Popup context menu appears instantly Items can be set as immovable (i.e., handwriting, shapes, etc.) |
Handwriting Recognition | Real-time (recognized as you write it) | You need to index a note for it to happen | Real-time (recognized as you write it) | No | Real-time (recognized as you write it) |
Handwriting Conversion | No | A popup presents you with the recognized text, which you can then copy or export; original handwriting remains | Available in Documents and Notes, but handwriting is deleted and replaced with text | No | A popup presents you with the recognized text, which you can then copy to the clipboard or convert into a textbox |
Handwriting Search | Global and in-document; available immediately after writing | Global and in-document; words in a note are searchable after indexing | Global and in-document; available immediately after writing | No | Global and in-document; available immediately after writing |
Tags | No | No, though pages can be added to an “outline,” with a term/name, and search results can be filtered to outline terms only | No | Yes, with manager/tag tool; tags appear in sidebar (list is not collapsible) for “quick filter” Tags are deleted from the system if no notebook is currently using it | Yes, with manager/tag tool; tags appear in sidebar (collapsible list) for “quick filter” Tags are deleted from the system if no notebook is currently using it |
Shapes | Solid, outline, and dashed outline; rectangles, ellipses, triangles, diamonds, stars, arrows No polygon tool Only the triangle and arrow shapes allow some vertex customization (but it can’t draw obtuse triangles) | Sketch-and-hold Vertex location can be edited after creation | Sketch-and-hold (basic shapes only: circle, quadrilateral, triangle) Available in Notes but not Documents | Sketch-and-hold Vertex location can be edited after creation (except on rectangles); vertices are displayed along with a popup menu (duplicate, delete, style, resize, etc.) as soon as the shape is created Shape tool can produce non-geometry shapes (star, speech bubble, rounded rectangle, capsule, etc.) along with standard shapes, but no arrows; these shapes are solid | Sketch-and-hold Vertex location can be edited after creation (except on rectangles), but you have to tap on the shape with your finger to reveal them Shape tool produces lines, arrows, ellipses, and polygons (vertices are not editable, only scalable) |
Notes
Category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Templates (Backgrounds) | Nine to choose from About a dozen preset paper and line colors, but you can create your own, too S, M, or L spacing | About a dozen different ones; you can import your own from an image or file; each page can have a different background 3 preset paper colors (B, W, yellow) but you can create your own (as well as the color of the lines) Lots of notebook cover designs | Documents: 1 template (lined); Notes: 4 templates (grid, lined, dots, blank) No size customization; 8 background colors | Many different designs About a dozen preset paper and line colors, but you can create your own, too | Just 5 (plain, ruled, legal, grid, dotted), but their line spacing is customizable (4 “heights”) Four preset paper colors, but you can choose any Line color is set by app (black/ish on light backgrounds, white/ish on dark) Template “store” with dozens of specialty paper (these aren’t editable other than light or dark theme) You can create your own templates from pdfs and images |
Layers | No | No | No (you can place multiple Notes on/in a Document, though not on top of each other) | Yes | No |
Writing Area | Notes are “infinite” and can scroll either H or V You can only add pages via the menu; unlike the other apps, you can’t just swipe up or down to create a new page Available area essentially the same as Noteshelf w/out the option to hide the toolbar | Fixed size; you can choose to scroll pages V or “flip” them H Menu/toolbar takes up most space out of any of the apps | Documents only scroll V, but are “infinite;” Notes can scroll H and V Slightly larger writing area than GN | Fixed size; you can choose to scroll pages V or “flip” them H Move vertical space, but less horizontal space, than Nebo | Fixed size; you can choose to scroll pages V or “flip” them H Most area available for writing, especially when the toolbar and palette are hidden |
Zoom Editing Window | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes (very customizable) |
Moving Pages | Pages can only be moved within a note | Pages can be moved from one notebook to another (placed at end of recipient notebook) in one step | [A page is a note; see “Moving Notes and Folder” below] | Pages are moved between notebooks using copy-and-paste, so you choose location in recipient notebook | Pages can be moved from one notebook to another (placed at end of recipient notebook) in one step |
File System
Category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
What is a “file” and what is a “folder?” | A file is a note: each note can have multiple pages that follow each other A folder contains notes and other folders | A file is a notebook: each notebook can have multiple pages that follow each other A folder contains notebooks and other folders | A file is a note. A folder is a notebook: it can contain multiple files (i.e., notes) A collection contains notebooks. | A file is a notebook: each notebook can have multiple pages that follow each other A folder contains notebooks and other folders | A file is either a notebook or a “quick note:” both can have multiple pages that follow each other, but a notebook also has a cover A folder is a category; folders only exist in the sidebar |
File Organization [make sure to read previous row for definitions of folder, notebook, etc. that each app employs] | Unlimited folder levels Icon view Folders can be rearranged and restacked in sidebar Sidebar displays your folders as well as All Notes, Favorites, and PDF filters You can import PDFs, scan documents, start new notes, or add folders within a folder | Unlimited folder levels List and icon view Sidebar displays Documents, Favorites, and Shared filters; global search and “marketplace” are also present You can import images, photos, files, scanned documents; and add notebooks or quicknotes to a folder | Icon view Collections are top-level folders that house notebooks Folders (including collections) are only accessible in the sidebar As notebooks can’t contain notebooks, subfolder organization is impossible You can import as PDF, start a new Note, or start a new Document in a folder | Unlimited folder levels Icon view (you can change the size of the icons; at least six levels of zoom) Folders can be rearranged and restacked in sidebar Sidebar lists your folders as well as Untagged, Unfilled, Trashed, and Pinned filters Files and folders are moved using select-and-choose destination folder or using drag-and-drop to sidebar You can import files, scan documents, start new notes, or add folders within a folder | Categories are top-level folders that house notebooks; they are only accessible in the sidebar Sidebar displays your categories as well as Home, Starred, Unfiled, Content, and Tag filters, as well as the Template “shop” Notebooks can be moved between categories via drag-and-drop to sidebar or using select-and-choose destination Notebooks can be grouped, creating a folder-esque file system You can import files, scan documents, take photos; and add audio notes, notebooks, and quick notes to a folder |
Moving Notes and Folders | Files and folders are moved using a tap-and-hold popup menu (single item) or by using the “select-and-choose destination folder” method (multiple items) | Files are moved using select-and-choose destination folder | Notebooks can be moved between collections via drag-and-drop in sidebar Pages/files are moved between notebooks by drag-and-drop to sidebar Pages/files can be reordered in Finder view by drag-and-drop in main window | Notebooks can be moved between folders using drag-and-drop to folders in the sidebar or using the select-and-choose method | Notebooks can be moved between folders using drag-and-drop to folders in the sidebar or using the select-and-choose method |
Importing | Create new page from image, scan, or imported file (Files app) You can add images, photos (i.e., use the camera), scanned documents, and files to a page | Create new page from image, scan, camera, or imported file (Files app) You can add images and photos to pages | Create new page by importing file as pdf You can add images and photos to a page | Create new page from image, scan, or imported file (Files app) You can add images and photos to pages | Create new page from image, scan, camera, or imported file (Files app) You can add images, photos, and other media to pages |
Exporting | Export as pdf, jpg, or Element file Select one page, multiple pages, or entire note | Share collaboration link; presentation mode; print Export as pdf, image, or GN file Select one page, multiple pages, or entire notebook | Share link via MyScript account Export Document as text, pdf, Word, or Nebo file Export Note as pdf, png, svg, or Nebo file | Export (it’s called Share here) as pdf, image, zip, or Noteful file Quality of graphics can be adjusted Select one page, multiple pages, or entire notebook | Export as pdf, image, or Noteshelf file Select one page, multiple pages, or entire notebook |
Other
Category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Supports Multiple Windows | Yes | Yes (can also be initiated from within the app) | No | Yes | Yes (can also be initiated from within the app) |
Desktop (Mac) App* | Yes | Yes | No | Yes (but for M1s only) | Yes |
Notables
Category | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Unique Features | Allows for multiple “infinite” notes inside a single notebook You can add Unsplash media to a note | Presentation mode | Converts math equations into text (Documents only) Diagram tool (Documents only); mind-map-esque Handwriting recognition can “detect” coding indentation and braces (e.g., if you want to write out a Swift struct, the text conversion will indent like in Xcode) | Tape (hides objects for testing memory): rectangular, linear, freeform Ruler tool You can hid the iPad status bar (time, date, battery level) | You can add web clips and media from Unsplash and Pixabay from inside the app You can record audio to a notebook page Presentation mode |
Best Quality | Cleanest interface | Has the most features | Handwriting recognition | Clean interface | Lots of features |
Biggest Negative(s) | No tags | The price is more than three times any of the others | Horrible file management No tags | No handwriting recognition | Lack of a true folder system and no left-side toolbar |
Verdict
Here’s the table summing up how each app handles my five most important features:
App | H.writing | Tags | Toolbar | Eraser | File Struct. | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
E. Note | -/0/+ | – | – | [+] | + | 6 – 9 |
Goodnotes | o | o | o | o | [+] | 7 |
Nebo | [+] | – | – | + | – | 6 |
Noteful | – | [o] | [+] | o | + | 8 |
Noteshelf | + | o | o | o | o | 7 |
How annoying is that? The highest scoring app is the one that I absolutely can’t use. Each app except Noteshelf is the best at one of the five things I’m most looking for. Noteshelf and Goodnotes are the second best, which makes sense given that both have all five features, but Noteshelf gets the nod because its less than a third of the price of Goodnotes.
I would choose Noteful if it recognized and searched handwriting–it even uses layers, which I would find very useful (but definitely not critical), but I went with Noteshelf. It’s not spectacular, but it’s solid and currently the best overall option: it has a lot of features and a pleasant interface.
Summary
Nebo feels like it’s just there to recognize your handwriting, and any other features are just… extra.
Goodnotes is bloated–lots of quantity (for lots of dollars) but average quality; it’s the Supernote of the apps I focused on.
Element Note is best for users who are only concerned about pen and eraser customization; it’s of the “It doesn’t do much, but what it does do, it mostly does very well” variety.
Noteshelf is much slimmer than either the stuffed-to-the-gills Zoomnotes or Goodnotes, despite having a lot of features (for a third of the cost in Goodnotes’ case). However, I don’t feel that any of those features other than text recognition are top-notch. (I’ve also run into many random, minor glitches and UI goofs–like incorrect borders or sizing on menus–but it’s easy to submit reports to their team, and they’ve already updated the app several times during the weeks it took for me to build this review.
Noteful is the best choice for anyone who doesn’t need the handwriting search/recognition feature.
Remember: all of the apps mentioned on this page that I tried have a free version and most allow you to inspect all the features–you just can’t have more than 2 or 3 notes stored. So try them all out before you decide, even the ones I didn’t compare, because one of them might be exactly what you want.